Therefore, let us leave the elementary doctrine of Christ and go on to maturity, not laying again a foundation of repentance from dead works and of faith toward God, 2 and of instruction about washings, the laying on of hands, the resurrection of the dead, and eternal judgment. 3 And this we will do if God permits. 4 For it is impossible, in the case of those who have once been enlightened, who have tasted the heavenly gift, and have shared in the Holy Spirit, 5 and have tasted the goodness of the word of God and the powers of the age to come, 6 and then have fallen away, to restore them again to repentance, since they are crucifying once again the Son of God to their own harm and holding him up to contempt. 7 For land that has drunk the rain that often falls on it, and produces a crop useful to those for whose sake it is cultivated, receives a blessing from God. 8 But if it bears thorns and thistles, it is worthless and near to being cursed, and its end is to be burned.
Let’s look at the characteristics of this sin as the text sets them out:
First, the person is said to have been enlightened, verse 4. The person confesses that they see clearly the issue of sin, who they are as a sinner and who God is as the righteous One.
Second, they have tasted the heavenly gift. That is to say, they begin to experience in their living a different kind of life than the life they used to live. And they realize there is a marked difference in the lives of those who have taken these experiences from God and loved them, and those who have not.
Third, That have a share in the Holy Spirit. The Spirit is at work and must be at work if a man or woman is to BE enlightened. The effect and beauty of God the Holy Spirit has been seen, even experienced.
Fourth, they have tasted and seen the good word of the Lord. The message about Jesus the Christ as the One who rescues and restores the fallen is like a cool drink of water on a hot, hot day, refreshing when you didn’t realize just how thirsty you were.
Fifth, there is a tasting of the power of the coming age. The new creation that God has promised, has already begun in Jesus Christ and this reality has come over a person, even creating a desire for this day to come in fullness.
Remember Jesus spoke of those who received the Word with joy…they took it in and were happy about it! They made a beginning, but then later had their faith choked by the cares of the world, the love of money or because of trials and sorrows, gave it all up.
My guess is that some of you have seen this; A dramatic and wonderful conversion only to see it come to nothing. The joy you saw seemed real enough, the person seemed to understand and embrace what was being said and happening. But a year later or longer the person was living as though none of that happened, and they are right back where they were before. Whatever these phrases mean, we can be sure the text is saying that there was some kind of a beginning, but there was no happy conclusion.
The person walks away and is glad to walk away…even arrogant and vitriolic…about their new found rejection of Jesus as the Christ of God. They don’t care, nor do they fret about what they have just left behind. That is apostasy.
Perhaps as you read all of this, you have no questions…no problems with the plain reading of the text. Some people experience enlightening, tasting of heaven’s gift, sharing in the Holy Spirit, tasting the good word of God and the powers of the coming age…making a beginning in all of this…and then deciding, Nah…what a crock…I want nothing to do with this Christianity nonsense…and walk away forever and are glad for it.
Again, some of you might be thinking, “Well yeh, what’s the big controversy, that is what it says.” Part of me wants to say, if that is you, then you are excused. But then again, maybe it would be of help to understand the conflict. Some will say that this description is NOT really true of the person, they didn’t really taste of the heavenly gift, or the word of God. They didn’t REALLY have a share in the Holy Spirit or the powers of the coming age…it only seemed to us that they did.
This perspective says of the branches mentioned in John 15, that were in the vine, were not REALLY in the vine…they were not REALLY in Christ, they only seemed to be in Christ. And they want to say that, because they are zealous to maintain certain doctrines, namely that you can’t truly have those things and lose them…that would be tantamount to losing salvation and we know, we good Reformed folks, that you cannot lose salvation if you have indeed been given it.
Therefore, those who are said in this text to have lost it…didn’t really lose it because they didn’t really ever have it. That is their argument…based on their systematic theology. Other Reformed folks will say, come on now, don’t let your theological categories…that is your Systematic Theology, dictate what a text means before allowing the text to speak for itself.
Wouldn’t we agree that if someone is born into the church, and for years enjoy the fellowship of the church, the teaching of the church, they embrace what they hear, confess their sins, seek virtue that aligns with Christianity…confess the creed, give themselves to Christian discipline and celebration…and then throw it all away and do so defiantly and bitterly…Would we not agree that such a person is not the same as our next-door neighbor who never has stepped inside a Christian church and who has never had interest in the things of Jesus Christ?
And what is it that makes this apostate different than the one who never believed?
The text says these apostates, those whose final state is rebellion and hatred of God and His Christ, did at one time enjoy things that true believers enjoy…and that this is the basis for the extremity of God’s condemnation of them. They had something, something beautiful, other-worldly, something that could have been life-giving…and they, in arrogance threw it away.
Now, have I just squelched the long-standing debate from this text once and for all? Oh goodness no. But I hope it has pushed us to see that in these deeper things, built upon the foundation that the author mentions, that it is possible to make a real beginning and fail to reach the Promised Land. And that this would work in us, a resolve to never, never stray from the One who has promised to take us there.
There will be those who once were a part of the faithful, but in the end will not be. But, the preacher of the sermon we called Hebrews, is simply saying to us, “Make sure, that you live your life so that this will never be true of you.”
That is what the stark warnings of the Bible are for…do not fear…do not explain them away…let them do their work.
Prayer: Father, in Your mercy hear my prayer, open my lips and my heart that I might know that my help comes from You the maker of heaven and earth. Help me to speak what is true to others and to myself. May I recount the goodness of my God to my own soul, calling myself to faithfulness, joy and peace that I might honor my King and Savior through Jesus Christ my Lord, Amen.